“We tried that already.” Five words that can stop a sales conversation in its tracks. You've probably heard some version of this from a buyer. Maybe they tried a similar product, worked with a competitor, hired a consultant, or invested in a solution that promised results they never saw.
And what happens next?
The salesperson immediately starts explaining why their solution is different.
“Our approach is more customized.”
“We've improved the technology.”
“That's exactly why our solution works better.”
Sound familiar?
I understand the instinct. When someone tells us they've tried something similar and it didn't work, we want to show them why our solution will.
But there's a problem with that approach.
We're trying to change the buyer's mind before we understand how they made it up in the first place.
And that can cost us the opportunity to have a meaningful sales conversation.
That's why I created Sell-Me.ai, an AI-powered sales coaching platform designed to help salespeople practice real-world conversations and receive feedback on their skills.
Explore Sell-Me.ai and start practicing the conversations that matter.
When a buyer says they've tried something before, they're sharing something important about their experience.
They may have invested significant time and money into a solution that didn't deliver what they expected.
Maybe the implementation was difficult. Maybe their team didn't adopt it. Maybe the solution worked, but the business wasn't ready for the changes required to make it successful.
Or perhaps the solution itself wasn't the problem.
There are a lot of possibilities.
But we won't know which one matters unless we ask.
A buyer's previous experience shapes what they believe is possible, what they're willing to risk, and how they evaluate the next opportunity.
And those beliefs don't disappear because we have a compelling presentation or a better product.
They become part of the decision-making process.
Think about what happens when you hear a buyer express skepticism.
Do you become curious?
Or do you feel the need to defend your solution?
For many salespeople, an objection creates discomfort. We worry the opportunity is slipping away, so we start searching for the right response to keep the conversation moving.
We explain more. We provide examples. We talk about successful customers.
And sometimes we do all of that without asking a single question about what the buyer actually experienced.
I've coached thousands of salespeople, and one of the things I consistently work on is helping them recognize how their own beliefs and assumptions influence their behavior.
When we assume an objection means the buyer isn't interested, we may respond defensively.
When we assume we already know what went wrong with their previous solution, we stop listening.
And when we're more concerned about keeping the opportunity alive than understanding the buyer, our questions tend to reflect that.
The question isn't how quickly you can overcome an objection. It's how well you understand what's behind it.
Let's say you're speaking with a buyer who tells you:
“We invested in sales training two years ago. It didn't make a difference, and we're not interested in doing that again.”
You could immediately explain why your sales training program is different.
Or you could get curious.
Here are five questions I would consider asking.
This helps you understand what the buyer was trying to accomplish and what mattered when they made their original decision.
Were they trying to improve win rates? Shorten sales cycles? Help managers become better coaches?
Without that context, you may be solving a problem they no longer consider a priority.
Expectations influence how buyers judge success and failure.
If the buyer expected an immediate improvement in revenue but the program focused on long-term behavior change, there may have been a disconnect between what was promised and what was measured.
Understanding those expectations can reveal why the experience was disappointing.
Now we're moving from assumptions to evidence.
Did the team attend the training? Were managers involved? Did salespeople practice the skills afterward? Was there a process for reinforcing what they learned?
Listen carefully.
The buyer may describe a problem that had very little to do with the solution itself.
This question helps you understand the buyer's interpretation of the experience.
And that's important because two people can experience the same event and come away with very different conclusions.
You don't have to agree with their interpretation.
But you do need to understand it before you can help them consider another perspective.
Here's where the conversation becomes especially valuable.
You're asking the buyer to identify what would make a future investment worth considering.
Maybe they need stronger leadership involvement. Maybe they want clearer performance metrics. Maybe they need confidence that their team will actually use what they learn.
Now you have something meaningful to discuss together.
And notice what you haven't done.
You haven't delivered a pitch.
You've helped the buyer examine their previous experience and identify what matters moving forward.
There's another reason these conversations matter.
Sometimes buyers become so focused on avoiding another disappointing investment that they stop considering the cost of leaving the problem unresolved.
They've decided that because one solution failed, attempting something different isn't worth the risk.
But what is happening while they wait?
Are their salespeople still struggling to reach decision-makers?
Are deals continuing to stall?
Are managers spending time coaching without seeing changes in behavior?
Those problems have costs, too.
The goal is to help buyers examine both sides of the decision.
What might happen if they try something different?
And what happens if they continue doing what they're doing?
You can't answer those questions for them.
You can, however, ask questions that help them evaluate the evidence, challenge their assumptions, and reach a decision they feel confident making.
That's where consultative selling becomes valuable.
I teach salespeople to approach conversations from the buyer's perspective.
That means understanding how buyers think, what influences their decisions, and what they need to feel confident moving forward.
It also requires us to recognize our own assumptions.
When a buyer tells us a previous solution failed, we may immediately assume we know why.
Maybe we've heard the same story from other customers.
Maybe we've seen similar situations.
But this buyer has a different experience, different priorities, and different people involved in the decision.
Their story deserves our attention.
Buyer First™ selling asks us to listen before we recommend, question before we assume, and help buyers make informed decisions rather than trying to persuade them toward ours.
And sometimes the best outcome of a discovery conversation is realizing that our solution isn't the right fit.
That's valuable information for both sides.
The next time a buyer says, “We tried that already,” pay attention to your first instinct.
Do you want to explain why your solution is better?
Do you start thinking about the perfect objection-handling technique?
Or do you genuinely want to understand what happened?
Try asking one more question before you offer your perspective.
You may discover that the buyer's hesitation has very little to do with your product or service.
And everything to do with what happened the last time they trusted someone to solve the problem.
You can't change a buyer's previous experience. But you can help them think differently about what they've learned from it.
And that's a much better place to begin a sales conversation
Please comment below and share it with someone you know!