Sales hiring mistakes rarely announce themselves.
They don’t show up as a single failed deal or a missed quarter. They surface slowly—in stalled pipelines, unreliable forecasts, team friction, and leaders spending more time managing issues than building momentum.
And by the time the pattern is clear, the cost has already compounded.
Transform your audience's approach to sales.
Carole teaches audiences that attitudes toward an action affect our ability to perform it — meaning that if we want to perform better in sales, we must adopt more positive attitudes toward sales. And it starts with putting buyers first.
Ready to transform your sales team’s outcomes? Book your next Keynote event today!
When the Market Rewarded Speed Over Judgment
A few years ago, the market didn’t reward patience.
There was a hiring surge.
Candidates moved quickly.
Companies hired just as fast.
Seats were filled to keep up, not to get it right.
Not long after that period, I worked with a leadership team that had “grown” their sales organization rapidly.
On paper, the team looked strong. Headcount was up. Coverage ratios appeared healthy.
In reality, nearly half the team was already on performance plans.
Pipeline stalled once we looked beneath the surface. Deals lingered. Forecasts slipped. A small number of top performers were quietly carrying the number while leadership tried to diagnose the problem.
It wasn’t effort.
It wasn’t motivation.
It was fit.
They had hired for speed, not for how selling actually worked inside their organization.
Fast hires don’t always fail fast. They fail quietly, and the damage shows up later.
THE DAMAGE THAT HAPPENS IN THE MIDDLE
This is where most organizations underestimate the cost of a miss.
Fast hires lead to fast exits—but the real damage lives in the middle:
- Opportunities that stall without clear explanation
- Customers who disengage mid-cycle
- Pressure placed on the wrong people to “save” the quarter
Leaders stuck coaching around issues that hiring should have prevented
Sales hiring mistakes don’t just affect the individual hire. They distort the entire system.
The Shift Leaders Are Making Now
Today’s environment looks different.
Hiring has slowed.
Uncertainty is higher.
Budgets are tighter.
Approval loops are longer.
Yet companies are still hiring.
What’s changed is the posture.
Leaders are finally saying the quiet part out loud:
“I can’t afford to miss on this hire.”
That mindset shouldn’t be reserved for uncertain times.
Salespeople are the lifeblood of your business. No revenue. No growth. No company. When a sales hire misses, the cost shows up everywhere—pipeline gaps, churn, culture strain, and leadership distraction.
A LEADERSHIP MOMENT THAT CHANGES THE OUTCOME
I saw this play out differently with another client.
Before opening a single role, the leadership team paused and aligned on one question:
What does success actually look like in this role six months in?
Not activity.
Not effort.
Outcomes.
They redesigned the interview process around real scenarios the salesperson would face. Candidates were asked to think, adapt, and explain—not perform.
It took longer to hire.
But the first hire ramped faster than any previous one.
The second became a benchmark for the rest of the team.
Hiring discipline didn’t slow them down.
It changed the trajectory.
WHAT DISCIPLINED SALES HIRING ACTUALLY LOOKS LIKE
The leaders who get this right don’t rely on gut feel alone.
They:
- Define success before sourcing candidates
- Ask questions that reveal judgment, learning ability, and adaptability
- Test how someone sells, not just how they interview
- Align hiring decisions to how revenue is truly generated in the organization
They don’t confuse confidence with competence.
They don’t assume experience equals effectiveness.
Discipline in hiring isn’t about moving slower. It’s about being precise.
WHY THE CANDIDATE EXPERIENCE MATTERS MORE THAN YOU THINK
Here’s the part many organizations miss.
The hiring process itself sends a signal.
When hiring is thoughtful and disciplined, the candidate experience improves. In my work with clients, one pattern shows up consistently: top performers lean toward rigorous hiring processes.
They want clarity.
They want challenge.
They want to know the bar is real.
Strong candidates aren’t scared off by standards.
They’re repelled by chaos.
HIRING RIGHT IS A LEADERSHIP CHOICE
Markets will change. Hiring cycles will expand and contract.
But one thing remains constant:
Sales hiring deserves discipline—every time.
Not because the market demands it.
Because the role does.
Leaders who get this right build sales teams that perform consistently, scale sustainably, and create trust across the organization.
And those results don’t come from hiring fast.
They come from hiring well.
Hiring a sales role right now?
Make sure your process attracts top performers—and protects your revenue.
Watch the On-Demand Session. In this video, Carole Mahoney, Author of Buyer First and Harvard Business School Entrepreneurial Sales Coach, and Ben Tagoe, CEO of Objective Management Group, share what they have learned about what it takes to have a successful sales and hiring process to avoid the costly mistakes so many make.
